Celebrating Black History: Calvin E. Simmons (Conducting ’73)

Born in San Francisco, California, on April 27, 1950, Calvin Eugene Simmons showed prodigious musical talent at a very young age. As a child, he took piano lessons from his mother, Mattie Pearl Simmons, and joined the San Francisco Boys Chorus at age 9, eventually conducting the ensemble at age 11 under the encouragement and guidance of music teacher and choral director Madi Bacon. In 1970, he entered Curtis, where he studied piano under Rudolf Serkin and conducting under Max Rudolf, withdrawing in 1972 for a conducting opportunity on the West Coast. He was awarded a certificate in conducting in 1973, appearing in that year’s graduating class photo.

Mr. Simmons returned home to California and became the repetiteur and assistant conductor of the San Francisco Opera from 1972 to 1975, winning the Kurt Herbert Adler Award. He made his formal debut conducting Giacomo Puccini’s La Bohème with revered Romanian soprano Ileana Cotrubas as Mimì. His subsequent work with the company on a production of Dmitri Shostakovich’s Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk drew national attention and garnered further conducting opportunities.

Listen to a San Francisco Opera lunchtime panel discussion with Calvin Simmons (conductor), Gerald Freedman (stage director), and Richard Rodzindki (whose father Artur Rodzinski was instrumental in bringing this opera to the U.S.) discuss Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk HERE.

From 1974 to 1975, he was a member of the Glyndebourne music staff in the United Kingdom, conducting performances of Mozart’s Così fan tutte that year and returning in 1976 and 1977 for four additional productions and 37 performances. After working as assistant conductor of the Los Angeles Philharmonic under Zubin Mehta, Mr. Simmons became musical director of the Oakland Symphony in 1978 at age 28, leading the ensemble for four years as the first African American conductor of a major U.S. orchestra. He continued to conduct the Los Angeles Philharmonic on occasion, both at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion and at the Hollywood Bowl, with engagements that ranged from concerts featuring artists such as American jazz legend Carmen McRae, to conducting Gustav Holst’s The Planets and works by English composer William Walton.

In 1978, Mr. Simmons served as the music director of the Ojai Festival for one season, followed by his house debut at The Metropolitan Opera, conducting Engelbert Humperdinck’s Hansel and Gretel. He returned the following season to lead the orchestra in eighteen additional performances of the opera and garnered a reputation as a highly-esteemed opera coach.

Tragically, Mr. Simmons drowned at age 32 in a canoeing accident on Connery Pond, just east of Lake Placid, New York. His final concerts were three performances of the Mozart Requiem in the summer of 1982 with the Masterworks Chorale and the Midsummer Mozart Festival Orchestra. He was scheduled to conduct The Magic Flute at New York City Opera the month following his death. Calvin Simmons’s meteoric rise was as extraordinary as his musicianship. Even though his life was cut short, he still left behind a magnificent legacy that paved the way for generations of Black classical musicians.

Praise for Calvin Simmons:

“Calvin Simmons was an extraordinary human being and a superb musician. His story is one that should inspire people, especially young people, to go for the gold ring.”the late Beverly Sills, opera singer and chair of Lincoln Center.

Exequien for Calvin Simmons was composed in August of 1982, shortly after I learned of the death of Calvin Simmons at 32 from drowning. It was not a piece I planned. I was composing a scene in a ballet, where the protagonist enters the underworld, but the shade I kept meeting was Calvin, a hero of our time, not of ancient times. I composed this Exequien as a going-out for him, based on that ‘meeting’; the music shared material with the ballet but does not belong in it.

All memorials are in some way self-serving, since we are also feeling sorry for ourselves, I first encountered Calvin when he called and asked for a piece to play with his Oakland Symphony. He is still the only conductor of a full time professional orchestra with whom I have had this experience (it became a yearly event), and when he did perform my music, he did with devotion and flair. He established links to many composers, to young American performers, and to new listeners. He lived joyously, with abandon, for the present. Even my short pieces, so immediate in response, couldn’t escape his buoyancy, and became a measure for slow dance rather than a dirge.” —program notes by composer John Harbison

Please visit the Curtis Institute of Music Open Archives and Recitals (CIMOAR). Learn more about Curtis’s library and archives HERE.

Photo Credits: 1.) Oakland Symphony; Jack Mitchell. 2.)  “Wayback Machine: Oakland Symphony’s Calvin Simmons dies in 1982.” San Francisco Gate, Johnny Miller, August 16, 2007. 3.) Graduation photo from the Curtis Archives and Special Collections. 4.) “Streaming the First Century: Session 1: Shostakovich’s Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk, 1981, San Francisco Opera. 5.) President and General Manager of the Oakland Symphony, Harold Lawrence, with Calvin Simmons; Mary Morris Lawrence, Classical California KUSC. 6. “The African American Performer on the San Francisco Stage,” Museum of Performance + Design

Curtis Mourns the Passing of Chris Hodges, Former Longtime Director of Admissions

The Curtis Institute of Music is saddened to share the news that Chris Hodges, longtime director of admissions at the school, passed away on Sunday, February 12, at age 66.

Mr. Hodges joined the Curtis staff in 1995 and was an integral part of Curtis for 25 years. When he arrived at the school in the mid-nineties, he carved out the admissions office and made it his own. He welcomed countless prospective students and their families to Curtis each year, gave knowledgeable and memorable campus tours, and supported our faculty throughout the audition process. He was often spotted running between the campus buildings, ensuring that everyone felt welcome and positioned for success.

Supportive, funny, and always a generous colleague, Mr. Hodges was the first to offer his assistance or a shoulder to lean on. Above all, we remember how he truly cared for Curtis’s students. He supported and rooted for them throughout their journeys, from potential applicants to students to alumni and beyond. Chris loved Curtis and our community. And we loved him in return.

We extend our heartfelt sympathies to his brothers, Bruce and John; to his sister, Susan; to his mother, Barbara; and to all his friends, family, and colleagues. He will be deeply missed. 

Celebrating Black History: Blanche Burton-Lyles (Piano ’54)

Award-winning concert pianist and music educator Blanche Henrietta Burton-Lyles (’54), protégé of opera legend Marian Anderson, became the first Black female pianist to graduate from the Curtis Institute of Music and the first African American woman to perform at Carnegie Hall with the New York Philharmonic in November of 1947 at age 14, having won the Young Audiences Competition. Born on March 2, 1933, in Philadelphia to Anthony and Anna Blanche Burton, she was considered a child prodigy and was admitted to Curtis at age eleven in 1944, where she studied with celebrated Russian American pianist, Isabelle Vengerova. That year, she also played with the first African American symphony orchestra, the Philadelphia Concert Orchestra at Scottish Rite Temple.

Ms. Burton-Lyles’s father sang in the choir’s bass section at Union Baptist Church, one of the city’s oldest African American Baptist congregations. There, the young girl met Ms. Anderson, who encouraged her to pursue a career as a classical musician and would often invite her to entertain guests at her home following performances in Philadelphia. A concert career followed her studies at Curtis, with a performance at Yale University with the New Haven Symphony and subsequent recitals in England, Spain, and the United States throughout the 1950s and ’60s. During this time, she also spent fifteen years accompanying the Leroy Bostic and the Mellow Aires ensemble.

In the early 1960s, Ms. Burton-Lyles joined the Philadelphia Board of Education as a teacher and continued her academic studies at Temple University, where she received her bachelor’s degree in music education in 1971. She retired from teaching in 1993 and became the founder and president of the Marian Anderson Historical Society, Inc., acquiring the historical residences of the late celebrated contralto in 1998 and her birthplace in 2000. She made it her life’s mission to preserve Ms. Anderson’s legacy, cherished memorabilia, books, rare photos, and paintings. Today, the Marian Anderson Residence Museum has become a fixture in the Philadelphia community and supports young artists, classical and opera singers, instrumentalists, visual artists, and more with local performances and events that the society sponsors.

Ms. Burton-Lyles was the recipient of many awards and humanitarian honors in her lifetime, including the Shirley Chisholm Philadelphia Political Congress of Black Women Award for Achievement in Music in 1994 and the National Black Music Caucus Award for Outstanding Women in Music in 1995. In addition, for her tireless efforts to preserve Marian Anderson’s legacy, she received the Mary McLeod Bethune Award from the National Council of Negro Women in 2000 and the 2005 Sadie T. Alexander Award from the Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Inc. In 2004, she was honored with the Philadelphia 76ers’s Community Service All-Star Award. She also received the Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Inc.’s Edythe Ingram Award in 2006, the Martin Luther King, Jr. Drum Major Cultural Award in 2007, and the National Association of Negro Business and Professional Women’s Unsung Hero Award at Carnegie Hall that same year.

Blanche Burton-Lyles passed away on November 20, 2018, at age 85.

Photos taken from the Curtis Archives and Special Collections. Please visit Curtis Institute of Music Open Archives and Recitals (CIMOAR). Learn more about Curtis’s library and archives HERE.

Watch numerous interviews with Ms. Burton-Lyles at The History Makers HERE.

Read a tribute to Ms. Burton-Lyles in The New York Times HERE.

Photo Credits: 1. & 2.) National Marian Anderson Museum and The History Makers. 3.) Blanche Burton-Lyles and the piano studio of Isabelle Vengerova; Curtis Archives and Special Collections. 4.) Ms. Burton-Lyles and Curtis’s graduating class of 1954; Curtis Archives and Special Collections. 5. & 6.)  Ms. Burton-Lyles before recitals at the Curtis Institute of Music; National Marian Anderson Museum and The History Makers. 7.) Ms. Burton-Lyles in an undated photo; National Marian Anderson Museum.

Rene Orth (Composition ’16) First Place Winner of 2023 Art Song Composition Award

Curtis congratulates Rene Orth (Composition ’16), who won first prize in the 2023 National Association of Teachers of Singing (NATS) Art Song Composition Award for her song cycle, “Weave Me a Name.” Ms. Orth received $2,000 and the opportunity to have her work for soprano and piano performed at the 58th NATS National Conference, June 28 to July 2, 2024, in Knoxville, Tennessee. Additionally, the Cincinnati Song Initiative will program the cycle on a future concert.

The set of seven songs features poetry by Jeanne Minahan McGinn, Curtis’s senior associate dean of academics and Ruth W. and A. Morris Williams Jr. Chair of Liberal Arts. The work will receive its world premiere on March 17, 2023, in Roxy Grove Hall at Baylor University with soprano Emily Albrink and conductor, coach, and collaborative pianist Kathleen Kelly. The cycle, which will be featured on Ms. Albrink’s upcoming debut album, Force of Nature (April 28, 2023, on Lexicon Classics), will also be presented on March 21 at Notre Dame University and March 24 at the University of Louisville.

“Winning this distinctive award is an honor, especially as this song cycle was written in honor of Nancy Albrink, a passionate collaborative pianist, pedagogue, and mother. It’s a beautiful tribute to her. I am also very pleased that the cycle has received this recognition, as I truly believe that more song cycles about the modern female experience— beyond Frauenliebe—need to enter the repertoire and be available for female singers.” —Rene Orth

To read the full announcement, click HERE.

To learn more about Rene Orth, visit her official website HERE.

To learn more about Jeanne Minahan McGinn, visit her website HERE.

Watch Rene Orth’s 2016 opera, Empty the House, a world premiere Curtis Opera Theatre production in partnership with Opera Philadelphia and the Kimmel Center for the Performing Arts.

 

Q&A with Mezzo-Soprano Ruby Dibble

Mezzo-soprano Ruby Dibble, from Kansas City, Missouri, stars as Elle in the Curtis Opera Theatre’s production of Francis Poulenc’s gripping, one-woman monodrama, La voix humaine. Ms. Dibble entered the Curtis Institute of Music in 2019 and studies in the opera program with adjunct faculty member Julia Faulkner. All students at Curtis receive merit-based, full-tuition scholarships, and Ms. Dibble is the Margaret Aull Wynne and Milly E. Wynne Fellow.

 


 

What challenges have you faced while learning this role and embodying a character like Elle, one who carries the full dramatic weight of a one-person opera like La voix humaine?

One of my biggest challenges when learning this role has been being patient. This show took longer than expected to sink into my deep memory, and I had to frequently remind myself just to take it day by day and learn/ memorize small section by section so that eventually I would be able to string all of those small sections together into the entire show. Elle, as a character, is also a tough nut to crack. At face value, she can be viewed as a woman who is powerless while waiting on a man to call her back. When first learning the piece, I, too, thought that Elle was yet another portrayal of the “crazy ex-girlfriend” or woman dying of heartbreak. But, as I’ve worked with Marcus on this version of the show, it seems that Elle is actually a very strong person, and perhaps the 40 minutes of La voix humaine is the story of a woman transforming in the face of tragedy.

What do you love the most about performing in French and singing Poulenc’s music?

I grew up speaking French, so I feel at home in the language; I went to a French immersion elementary school and spoke exclusively in French from Kindergarten through 8th grade. Perhaps I’m biased, but I think French is the most beautiful language to sing in because of how the lines are often set up to facilitate stunning legato. Poulenc is funny about this, actually. He writes in direct opposition to the flowing line that French can provide for the singer. So much of La voix humaine borders on Sprechstimme or talking on pitch, and the vocal line is broken up in an extremely percussive way. But then, when Poulenc does give into the legato of the French language, his long sweeping musical lines are all the more meaningful. Poulenc’s choice of harmony reminds me so much of the Jazz harmonies of his contemporaries. My first musical love was Jazz, so I find it to be quite poetic to sing in this piece in a classical vocal style while being supported by such Jazz-like textures.

Click HERE to watch Ruby Dibble’s On Stage at Curtis episode from 2022, or click the video below.

“Technoference,” or the way technology interferes with human interaction, seems just as relevant in the 21st century as it was over six decades ago when Poulenc adapted Jean Cocteau’s play into an opera. In 1958, Elle’s mode of communication was a landline telephone, but Marcus Shields’s production is of the now. Why do you think audiences still connect so deeply with this character after all these years later?

Audiences today can connect with Elle’s story because now, more than ever, we are isolated by our technology. Elle longs for meaningful and honest communication from Monsieur but, instead, has to settle for just a phone conversation—a cheap imitation. Elle says to Monsieur, “if only you could see me, everything would be different, but with this phone receiver, that which is done is done.” If Elle and Monsieur could be in the same place and speak face to face, perhaps their situation could be remedied, and she wouldn’t feel so alone. Today, with smartphones and all the opportunities to connect with one another, our society has seemed to do the opposite. We struggle to call strangers on the phone, make eye contact, or even look up from our phones when crossing the street. Elle’s phone being the thing that is stopping her from having a meaningful connection is the same plight we face today.

The audience only hears your side of the story, not the silent “Monsieur” on the other line. What is your perception of this gentleman and his relationship with Elle? 

The beauty of this piece is that we really aren’t supposed to know all the details of Elle’s relationship with Monsieur. If Cocteau needed the audience to know exactly what is said between them, it would be a two-person play. With the backstory between Elle and Monsieur being so purposefully obscured, I’m sure every person who has taken on the role has a completely different version of that story. That being said, in our production, we have discussed the idea that there may be a significant age gap between the two lovers. Poulenc notes at the beginning of the score that Elle is an “elegant young woman” and that her breakup should have nothing to do with her getting older and Monsieur leaving her for a younger woman.

Later in the piece, Elle says that she has been with Monsieur for five years at this point. Bearing all that in mind, there is a chance that Elle could have been pursued by a man much older than her before she was ready for that kind of relationship. Other context clues in the text point to Monsieur being a wealthy man, a man who has an assistant or a butler named Joseph. Elle also briefly asks about a court case that Monsieur may be working on: “Quel Procès?” There could be a world where Monsieur is a high-profile lawyer who should not be seen with a woman as young as Elle, and perhaps that is why he ultimately chooses to marry someone else—perhaps someone who looks better in the public eye. It seems to me that their relationship was born out of secrecy and an unbalanced power dynamic, and ultimately that is what tips the scale to end their relationship.

Do you have any dream roles that you’d like to perform in the future, and why?

I would love to sing Bizet’s Carmen and Charlotte in Massenet’s Werther. Both are sung in French, which would be meaningful to a French speaker. As a performer who has done a lot of comedy, I am so intrigued to walk in the shoes of these tragic figures for a change. I am also a lover of Strauss, and I would be thrilled to get to sing Octavian in Der Rosenkavalier or Der Komponist in Ariadne auf Naxos

Interview by Ryan Scott Lathan. 

Read OperaWire‘s article about Ms. Dibble’s upcoming performance as Elle, featuring the piano accompaniment of master opera coach Lisa Keller.

Director Marcus Shields discusses his production of La voix humaine with Curtis Opera Theatre:  

Set in the present moment, the visual and audio aesthetic will be what director Marcus Shields calls “contemporary collage. ‘Collage’ refers to the conscious combination of elements—sound, video, and live performance—placed together. The technology used in the creation of the piece (cameras, microphones, etc.) will be in view of the audience. Essentially, there will be no attempt to hide any aspect of the room; however, all elements are very specifically chosen and arranged in a meaningful picture. The architecture of Curtis and the Black Box Theater will contribute heavily to the visual component” of the piece.

Mr. Shields continues, “This piece is a virtuosic emotional/vocal showcase for the performers, in our case, Ruby Dibble and Lisa Keller. It is a piece about the relationship between a human and another human, and it is a piece about the relationship between a human and technology. The opera was written some 65 years ago, but we are still very much struggling to sort out these same exact relationships. Maybe the stakes are even higher today. This production will try to place this all into a single frame.”

 

CURTIS OPERA THEATRE: La voix humaine
Love is on the line in Poulenc’s gripping psychological drama

February 14, 2023 | Tuesday at 7:30 p.m.

Curtis Institute of Music, Black Box Theater, 1726 Locust Street, Philadelphia

Marcus Shields, director
Ruby Dibble, mezzo-soprano
Lisa Keller, pianist

Click HERE for more information.

Visit Ruby Dibble’s official website HERE.

Photos of Ruby Dibble by Daniel Welch and Brian Paulette. Photo of Marcus Shields, courtesy of artist’s official website.